Sweet list there Tom.
Climbing up a huge stump. I am sure I am not the only one to be thinking about this issue...
So here goes;
I think today's music Industry shoots itself in the foot every time it backs performers who couldn't sing their way out of a bucket if they had to perform live with nothing to back them up. And the record companies are backing songs that really have nothing to it (like that dumb Fergie song "London Bridge"; if you really could call it a song). I just don't get it.
*eg. Witness how many countless times there have been recording artists singing the National Anthem for sporting events and not even being able to stay on pitch or have a great vocal range to begin with.
At least now the directors are able to feed the melodies and harmonies into the ear plug monitors to fool the audience into thinking some of these "look good but really cannot sing artists" actually sang the national anthem and stayed in the same key and nailed the pitches; all without botching the lyrics.
The music industry executives imo seems to spend most of its resources producing & promoting "music" for the kid and yuppie dollars; and they give us what they think the kids willl want to blow their money on.
Occassionally you will find a rare gem ( eg. Norah Jones, Michael Buble, Josh Groban )on todays popular music scene. Thank God for Jazz and Blues radio.
And some of the "popular" artists like Rod Stewert doing material from the American Songbook are helping to introduce the younger ears to great songs.Years ago; I never would have dreamed Rod Stewert would play a role in introducing songs from the American Songbook to the younger folks.
Those of us who love this music really should try to support our local high school music programs --- the kids that are being introduced to the swingy tunes of yesterday in our school jazz music programs may well be the key to getting more great music played more often.
Unfortunately; I think the few record company executives out there making the decisions as to what will be put on the market have to come around.
But who knows, maybe now that artists can be independent & produce their CDs much easier and sell them at their gigs , maybe more independent artists will find the treasured songs of the artists you listed above.
We who love this music have to do our parts to keep these songs around. Buy the music of todays artists that do these songs well like Buble & Krall. Go to their concerts (if you can afford to). See the legends who are still living... eg. Tony Bennett (remember the MTV show he did).
Support the school music programs. And if you do the songs well and play for folks; play those songs. Discussion of the songs publically on forums like this even will help such a noble cause.
I think there is a need for a American Songbook movement... as there was the folksong movement in the 60's. In some ways such a movement may be already getting started; but it is sure taking its time.
Time to get off the stump;
jmo
btw I think if Billy Joel had been writing songs back in the 30-40's he could have done some clever things also. He has a knack for clever lyrics, and of course serious music chops. (What was the name of that hit Broadway show of Billy Joel's?) Maybe one of the reasons he isn't doing music is because todays pop music scene doesn't keep him motivated in some way...
If the post is long, well I can only say that I feel strongly about keeping what is probably some of the best American Music in the public ear. We as musicians can all help to do that in our own ways.
I gotta get going now; I have a rehearsal tonight for an upcoming performance myself. Time to finally tear myself away from Piano World and youtube... and make some music myself.
Originally posted by tsarchitect:

You can't compare the melodic and harmonic content of the stuff you hear today with that composed by the GREATS -- Gershwin, Kern, Rodgers & Hammerstein/Hart, Berlin, Porter, et al.
Tom [/b]