"The more upbeats you have in the music the more it swings"

Dizzy Gillespie.

Forward Motion - Introduction - by Hal Galper

"My original three articles on Forward Motion were published in Down Beat Magazine in 1980 & 1981. Their purpose was to show how melodies work as well as offering a way of practicing scales more in the manner they are used than in the way they were originally learned. Since that time my understanding of the subject has grown and the way I use FM in my teaching has been modified. Originally, I used FM to correct what I saw as a technical and theoretical problem. Now I see FM exercises as being used to correct what are basically perceptual problems. As most problems with playing music are perceptual in nature, to change the way you play you have to change the way you think.

When the articles were first published, I was sure I had come upon original research that no one else had duplicated. It wasn't until I read Albert Schweitzer's biography of Bach (J.S. Bach, Vol. 1 & 2, Dover Books) that I realized that the musical laws inherent in FM were universal. Anyone exploring this subject would come to the same conclusions that Bach and I did. The rules that govern music are universal, not affected by the passage of time, place or genre. There are concrete reasons why some music sounds better than others.

In volume 1, Pg. 312 of the Schweitzer biography is his analysis of Bach's concept of phrasing. "If we follow the principle indicated by Bach's manner of writing his phrases, we see that he usually conceives four consecutive notes as grouped in such a way that the first is detached from the others by an imperceptible break, and belongs rather to the previous group than to the one that follows." Thus not



but


He gives the following phrasing example from Bach's Prelude in A minor (Peters II, No. 8):



On page 375 of the same volume (referring to Rudolf Westphal's metrical study of the fugues in Bach's Well-tempered Clavichord) "…he proves again and again that those who regard the bar-lines in Bach's music as the borders of the rhythmic factors are bound to play him unrhythmically. In a Bach theme everything surges forward to a principal accent. (Emphasis mine). Till this comes all is restless, chaotic; when it arrives the tension relaxes, and at one stroke all that went before becomes clear, - we understood why the notes had these intervals and these values." And again, on page 396 of volume 2 "If we do not experience this sense of tension followed by relief, the theme has not been properly played; it has been phrased in the ordinary rhythm of the bars, instead of in its fundamental rhythm."

Beginning with our earliest childhood education a tacit conditioning occurs. We see "one" of the bar before we see any other beat or note. We count first beat of the bar as "one." Since "one" is the first number of the number series, years of perceiving music this way has conditioned us into thinking of "one" as the first beat of the bar. It would then seem logical that melodic phrases begin on the first beat of the bar, or "one."

However, Tension and Release Theory states that "one" of the bar is the strongest beat of the bar and as such, is the ultimate resolution beat in the bar. "Resolution" means that something has ended, consequently "one" of the bar is not the first beat of the bar; it is the last beat of the bar. It is the beat to which melodic ideas are played toward and at which they end.

FM is based on the laws of the physics of sound and rhythm. These laws are immutable and as applicable in Bach's time as in ours. FM is also based upon the physiology of how the ear functions, another universal. The mind loves logic and rejects chaos. It has an innate tendency to want to make sense out of chaos. When faced with a problem or something that doesn't make sense, it automatically tries to make sense out of it by relating it to the familiar.

Such is the case, for example, when looking at a modern abstract painting by Klee. The mind tries to force the eye into making sense out of it by looking for ways to make the painting's content fall into recognizable representational objects: cars, trains, houses, animals, etc., as one does when looking at clouds. This same tendency is present in the ear as well. The ear tends to reject chaos and has a marked tendency to automatically make sense of the sounds it hears. To the ear, tension is intolerable and needs to be resolved. Have you noticed the problems you have going from one melodic fragment to another? How you have a hard time "hooking up" your ideas from one to the other? That's probably because you're starting your melodies on "one" and/or "three" of the bar. "One" is a resolution beat, a point of rest for the ear and stops the line. When starting a melody on a tension beat, the ear wants to resolve the tension by jumping ahead to it's nearest resolution beat. If you start on the "and" of "two," your ear will want to hear towards the resolution on the up-coming beat, "three" of the bar.

FM is a practicing technique that takes advantage of this innate tendency to hear an idea in motion toward future rhythmic and harmonic resolution points. This ability can be developed to a highly sophisticated degree.

All art is the projection of an illusion created by the artist. This is no less so for the musician. When listening to a jazz solo, it is perceived in a static fashion. You are being subjected to an illusion. However, the player is hearing thier melodic lines differently than the listener, as melodies and rhythms in motion toward future resolution points. Instead of hearing in a static manner, the soloist is hearing ahead of where they are in the music at the moment.

The ear can be trained to hear: two beats, four beats, two bars, eight bars ahead. The great jazz drummer, Billy Hart, once confided to me that he "hears" his whole chorus in approach to "one" of the next chorus. Since this is a natural innate ability, anyone can learn to hear and play in FM.


Forward Motion is divided into ten chapters:

Melody and Embellishment creates a historical context for the following chapters by creating a framework for understanding how the process of jazz improvisation became increasingly more sophisticated from its beginnings in the early 1900's. It explains the historical connection between how it was done then and how it is still done today, clarifies those aspects of improvising that have changed and those that haven't and why.

Rhythmic Forward Motion introduces the basic concept of Forward Motion, starting with how my study of it began and how music is almost universally taught "backwards" from the way it really functions. It describes the functions of Tension and Release patterns rhythmically and melodically and how they can be played to create strong melodies that "spell" the changes out. This chapter also includes a discussion of playing in half time and its effect upon a player's conception of playing in tempo ending with a short treatise on Rhythmic Syncopation.

Scalar Forward Motion applies Forward Motion techniques to scale lines and how "Key Scales" can be transformed into "Chord Scales." Three categories of scales lines are discussed: scale lines that descend for chords of two beats duration, scale lines that ascend for chords of two beat's duration, and scale lines that ascend and descend for chords of four or more beats duration. The chapter illustrates the almost infinite ways that chord tones can be synchronized with the strong beats of the bar to clearly "spell" out chord changes. The use of Inner Guide Tone Melodies is also discussed.

Arpeggios and Forward Motion elaborates on how to add pickups and resolutions to arpeggios giving them a feeling of motion demonstrating the difference between themes that are in and out of Forward Motion. It then applies the technique of Melodic Inversion to insure you have explored all the possible ways arpeggios of different lengths can be combined.

Appoggiaturas and Forward Motion shows how chromatic embellishments can be synchronized to spell out chord changes. An abbreviated list of some of the infinite ways chromatic embellishments have been used in the jazz vocabulary is included.

Intervals and Forward Motion adds pickups and resolutions to large intervals (broken arpeggios) to give them a feeling of motion including examples of their use by modern composers and how they might be used in a solo context.

Harmonic Forward Motion details the advanced technique of spelling out chord changes in advance of where they are written and how to make them work within a solo line. It illustrates how current transcriptional analysis leads to misconceptions about how a soloist has spelled out the chord changes.

Forward Motion and Pentatonics and Cells applies Forward Motion techniques to pentatonic scales, arpeggios and "Cell Playing" as well as how to delineate their Inner Guide Tone Melodies.

Superimposition is an advanced technique describing how musical freedom from the predictable elements of music: meter, harmony, melody and form can be achieved. Otherwise known as "being able to play anything anywhere," it illustrates how the masters used these elements only as guides to made up their own solo content over the predictable elements to create rhythmic and melodic freedom during a solo.

How To Practice Forward Motion debunks mechanical "repetition" as an outmoded practicing process. It offers a step-by-step process for retraining your hearing to hear in Forward Motion.


THE ORAL TRADITION

Unlike western music, jazz's roots derive from the African oral tradition. In western cultures information is transmitted from generation to generation by the written word. In African culture, information, such as stories, family history, music, social customs and laws, are handed down through succeeding generations by the spoken word and demonstration. Western music is taught in a classroom environment. Concepts are broken down to their smallest increments, analyzed to yield their meaning, then reconstituted to recreate the whole concept.

African music is taught in the Master/Student format. The student lives with the master, cleans his house, cooks, does his laundry. The student, through daily contact with the master, absorbs the master's thought processes. One-on-one individual lessons are the norm. The master plays a musical idea, for an example, a rhythmic pattern like: Dum, Dum, De, Dum, De De Dum, instructing the student to "make it sound like this." The music is taught by demonstration and copying. Copying not only what the master played but also how the master played it. This defines the crucial difference between the western and African teaching methodology. Western methodology interposes the intellectual process of theory and analysis between the teacher and student. The African methodology involves the student directly in the sound and the feel of the music, bypassing the intellect by the process of copying. The western process is standardized, often stifling the development of one's original voice. The African process stimulates and encourages this development.

Africa's cultural history is handed down through succeeding generations by story telling. Each new generation tends to embellish their recitations. Each new version of the stories are imbued with their own individual idiosyncrasies. In this manner, the style in which the story is told may be personalized but its true meaning is never altered. Value is not only placed on remaining true to the basic traditional meaning of the story but on each story teller presenting these traditions in their own individual voice.

Similarly, a jazz musician's two primary goals are to not only absorb the traditions of the music but to develop their own individual musical voice as well. Copying, imitation, "make it sound like this," insures that both goals are achieved simultaneously. For this reason, the process of copying has remained the central process for learning how to play jazz.

Jazz musicians of earlier decades didn't have available to them the awesome amount of music information that is available to contemporary jazz students. Their instructional resources were limited to the radio, live performances, recordings and the apprenticeship system. In those days the only way the music could be learned was by trying to emulate the music of the masters by copying them. The result was that, as in African story telling, each new generation learned the tradition of the music but played the tradition, each in their own individual voices. One might postulate that it was the very lack of this information that created the strong identifying stylistic characteristics of the early generations of jazz musicians.

Music sounds good because the "rules" of the music were used correctly. Music sounds bad because they weren't. Consequently, if one copies good sounding musical ideas from the tradition of the music, one is learning the rules of how to play good music on an intuitive, not an intellectual level. Copying gets the student directly into the sound and vocabulary of the music. The history of the jazz vocabulary contains the rules of the music within it. Most of the great masters I had the good fortune to apprentice with throughout my career learned by copying and played by ear. Most, if asked to name what they played, couldn't. But they could show you how to play by hearing them night after night, playing it right, so you could hear it and through the process of trial and error, eventually emulate their playing. In this manner the history of the tradition was retained through newer generations. Each newer generation found their individual way to play it without altering its basic verities and as in African storytelling, retained its true meaning.

As this music is learned by listening and copying then understanding what you are hearing and copying is a crucial element of the learning process. Forward Motion insures that you are hearing the music correctly by copying and practicing it correctly.


"Attitude Is Everything" (Jazz Proverb)

Webster's Dictionary defines the word "proverb" as "a maxim of wisdom… An allegorical saying of the wise that requires interpretation." The roots of jazz music are firmly planted in the oral tradition of African music. The oral tradition is the process masters of the music used to efficiently pass musical wisdom down to succeeding generations of musicians. This wisdom is usually experiential and difficult to record in written form. Jazz proverbs are ubiquitous throughout the history of jazz and are very powerful. They function on a conceptual level. The information they contain is experiential in nature, embodying enormous amounts information that, after much reflection by the student and guidance from a master, illuminate the subject. After lengthy consideration, they have the effect of changing a musician's mental, emotional and physical actions; their mental states, attitudes, conceptions and perceptions, the way musicians think and feel about themselves, the music and their relationships to their instrument, practice, performance and other players. They effect musical behavior achieving global, as opposed to incremental, changes upon their playing.

Over the years, both through research and personal experience apprenticing with the masters, I have concentrated my efforts on collecting, analyzing and explicating these jazz proverbs to unlock the information they contain. All my writings are derived from my investigations into this rapidly vanishing and most valuable, resource. It's the nature of these proverbs that you may or may not gain a complete understanding of it's meaning for decades. They are perceived at first as being one dimensional. They sound logical but the information in them is hidden. Their other dimensions are illuminated only after one has had enough experience and acquired enough knowledge to relate to the proverb personally. Throughout this book, I have used jazz proverbs, quoted both from jazz masters and of my own creation, followed by their explication. The greatest challenge that I, as author, and you as reader face, is my capability to not only explain these proverbs but to impact their meaning to the reader on a gut level, to change the way the you think."

http://www.forwardmotionpdf.com/book_intro.shtml

Interesting! I was just reading through a book on rhythm by James Morgan Thurmond called "Note Grouping." He expands Schweitzer's idea quite a bit and has several examples of how it works in performance.

My last teacher would have us play through the bar line--and pause on the first beat of the next measure before proceeding with that measure. A real pause. We would continue in this way, playing to the first note of the next measure. It really is a great way to practice FM and can get a piece from stalling to moving.

That eighth rest at the beginning of the Bach example bothers me...

In my opinion, forward motion is well created by anticipation--anticipating chords by an eighth note, etc. It is also created through implied dominant harmony. There are lots of nice forward motion tricks to do with soloing. If we're just jamming over a Dmin in modal Jazz style, my solo lines could borrow from A7alt, etc. A nice Dbmaj arpeggiation would also lead well into the Dmin solo lines.

Forward motion is also created through the pocket. How you stretch and contract time will create tension and relaxation, which is a contour in itself which provides a wealth of opportunities.

Really, to hear good forward motion in action be sure to listen to as much modal Jazz as possible. You have to be good at creating forward motion in order to make 128 bars of Dmin hold your attention.

I went to see and hear Sonny Rollins and his group on Nov 19th at the Scottsdale Center for the Arts and one of the tunes they played did not have more than three maybe four chords. What they played was outstanding and of course they played other tunes that had many changes but the point is the great jazz players explore many possibilities with the music and sounds and seem to be always reworking their approach to the same standards. Forward motion is a great book because it makes you think and gives you insight in to developing solo lines that sound good and make sense. DPVJAZZ

These examples are all repetitively symmetrical, basically 4 note cell-phrasing that's impetus is not on one, the downbeat. While this creates a certain amount of tension, only when sounded contrapuntally to another line, such as a walking bass line, the line itself doesn't gain as much momentum and propulsion as a line with non-repetitive cellular-phrasing subject to change and a feeling of almost random accent to the listener.

Just how much momentum is generated by playing groups of 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, etc. notes per beat with a regularly recurring repetitive accent or cell-phrasing is totatlly dependent upon the contour and phrasing of the counterpoint. By itself, after several patterns emerge, the ear transcends the shift of the downbeat and normalizes it, however, when your lines exhibit swing AND non-repetitive phrasing that stresses dynamic apexes within your stretches that fluctuate, some on the beat, some off the beat, the line itself, devoid of conterpoint, will always reperpetuate itself propulsively.