I only have a couple of months of piano lessons under my belt, but after discovering the joy of making music, I'm starting to be interested in other instruments as well. So I'm thinking of picking up a second instrument some time in the future. But there are so many beautiful instruments out there it's hard to choose! Here's a list of my candidates:

1) Violin :
the instrument I've always admired second to the piano. But I hear it's very hard to learn. You have to find and create the right notes, unlike with the piano where all the notes are already there. It might be doubly hard for me because I don't have a very good ear and am slightly tone deaf But if I had unlimited time and resources, I'd definitely pick up the violin!

2) Guitar :
there are lots of guitar shops and guitar players in my country. Guitars can be bought quite cheap. If I pick this up, I'll be leaning heavily towards classical or acoustic (what's the difference between the two?). I see a lot of music written for guitar, which is also an advantage.

3) Banduria /Ukulele/ mandolin :
I just like how small they are compared to a guitar And I feel they're more unique because guitars are everywhere!

4) Flute :
I haven't heard music played with flute that captured my heart (admittedly, I haven't heard a lot of music played in flute either!). What attracts me is how portable this instrument is. It's quite frustrating that I can't bring my digital piano with me to practice during the weekends! EDIT: saw some youtube videos and am now impressed with the tonal possibilities of flute.

5) Harp :
I absolutely love the sound of this instrument, but I think it's too big and heavy. And it's probably hard to get a teacher around here.


I won't be taking up another instrument this early in my piano studies, but I want to let the idea simmer for a while. Piano will probably always be my main instrument, so a secondary instrument will probably only get 30 minutes or so of practice in a day. Do you think a non-musical person like me can reasonably pick up a 2nd instrument?

Btw, I have no intentions of playing in an ensemble. Just solo.

Any advice/suggestions appreciated Are there other people playing other instruments around here?

I play guitar as well as the piano. Self-taught and pretty bad at it, but it taught me a lot about improvisation and some chord structures so I can sit at the piano and play without the sheet music I usually learn from.

I LOVE the sound of the harp. Unfortunately, it's really difficult to find a teacher in Barcelona, and the few available have very limited schedules.

Violin is in a league of its own. I wish I would have taken lessons as a child. Now, my neck bones wouldn't allow me to try to learn to play it.

Violin or harp would be my instruments of choice, were I given the opportunity.

Instead, I'm playing gralla, a typical folk Meditettanean instrument. It's the oboe's medieval precursor. I don't like it that much, but the Governement's Department of Traditional Culture pays for the lessons, the instrument and the rehearsal room.

Everything to play anything... *sighs*

Ages ago I played the clarinet, but without frequent practice I lost the ability to form the embouchure. The same is probably true of any woodwind or brass instrument.

I do play the banjo, and can fake the dobro (tuned very similar to the banjo). I know a few chords on the mandolin. The attraction of another instrument is the portability. You just can't take a piano with you on vacation.

A very popular instrument now is the ukulele. Only four strings, easy to play, and it doesn't require calluses on the fingertips like the mandolin.

So many instruments, so little time.

I have a hammered dulcimer, which is a shade more portable than a full-sized harp or a full-sized keyboard, but less so than a penny whistle There are folk harps which are smaller than a full-sized harp that would be fun.

Cathy

Marimimora, not my field of expertise, but it seems to me you probably do need some time to focus on one instrument before moving on to the next (similar to studying foreign languages) but sure it is fun to think of learning other instruments. Probably comes down to what interests you the most.

What are peoples' thoughts on the xylophone? I never hear it mentioned much but that would be my choice.

Something to consider is that as you progress in piano, you will need more practice time. Once you get to advanced levels, you'll be looking at at least 2 hours per day. I don't know about the other instruments in your list, but I do know about singing, and my time is quite divided maintaining two instruments at an advanced level. I love them both so there's no way short of a debilitating accident that I'd quit one or the other, but I often envy those who just focus on one. I'm not telling you not to do it, but just make sure you can devote the time needed to do both well.

I agree with Morodiene.
I have begun the piano a little bit more than one year ago without any musical background and, despite every advice, I've recently picked up the violin too (today was my 2nd lesson).So far it doesn't take too much of my time and it is quite fun !

However, the main issue is how you will manage your time. If you think you can add another practice time without cutting on your piano, go for it.

Concerning the difficulty of the instrument, it will surely take several years but keep your motivation :p

I hope that you have a budget for the extra teacher and for buying a violin (it is quite expensive - for the time being, I'm renting one).

I don't really know the other instruments but you don't seem really into them with the exception of the harp but the violin is much more portable (and you'll have more chances to find a teacher) !

I keep a pennywhistle in my backpack, and play it when I need to wait around for public transit or appointments or whatever. Also nice to take out into nature. It's hard to beat for portability.

I also mess around with various sizes of recorder, and recently picked up my first Irish flute (unkeyed). But I've always loved the sound of flutey things, so piano is actually the aberration for me. I started playing it again because I wanted to learn more about chords and harmony.

Thanks so much for the advice Certainly, I am not going to pick up another instrument at this point. I already had experience studying 2 languages at the same time in college and I agree the results weren't too pretty. The 2 languages messed up my head, and in the end, I ended up progressing much more in Japanese than my major, Spanish! However, I have a feeling that if I learned one or the other when I have built a reasonable intermediate-level foundation in one, I may have done better. This is what I'm planning to do when I do start on another instrument. My goal for piano is up to advanced level, but I'd probably be satisfied at a decent intermediate level for a second instrument.

It would still take a while, but want to think about it earlier so I'll be better prepared. I'm pretty good at budgeting so I can make sure that I can afford the lessons. But what surprised me is how expensive even starter instruments are! I thought since they were smaller than the piano, they'd be a lot cheaper. Cost-wise, I'm leaning towards classical guitar because there are so many guitar makers around here so the cost is relatively low. That'll make it easier to get my feet wet.

After researching a bit, I found out that I quite like all these instruments (they all have their particular charm). If only one had unlimited time, talent, and resources!


nan : The xylophone sounds interesting too! And the starter metal xylophones sell for cheap around here. I may look more into it.

You asked what was the difference between classical and acoustic guitar. Acoustic (as opposed to electric) guitars used for folk and pop music have steel strings and are mostly played with a pick. while classical acoustic guitars have nylon strings and are played with the fingers. Fingernails are a big deal to classical guitarists. My piano teacher's first instrument is the classical guitar, and he came in one day with a kind of a fake fingernail glued on because he had broken one and couldn't play his guitar without it.

To me having a second instrument is great. I am on my second year of flute playing and love it. When I get tired when practising the flute I sit down and practice a moment at the piano, and vice versa. And the best thing is that there are many more opportunities to play with others in ensebles and similar, wich I find is really a lot of fun and a motivation booster.

As for price, there are good beginner flutes that are not too expensive. I would recommend Yamahaa, which has a good reputation. But ask a teacher, or experienced player to help you. (By the way, I did not follow that advice myself, but instead bought a flute (a good choice fortunately) and then called the local music school looking for a teacher. I got a response from a terrific teacher. Well, at my very first recitial, as the only adult student, my teacher introduced me by telling about how I just a few moths ago had called and said that I have bought a flute and now need help to learn how to play it. )

Sorry, Now I got side tracked. You can also rent an instrument until you are sure you will continue playing.

I would say that if you choose violin you need to be prepared to be patient, really patient. It takes a lot of work to make the violin sound good, but if you stick to it I assume it is a beutiful instrument. I won two free violin lessons once at a student recitial, and it was great fun to try.

Thanks for the info, FormerFF! What a shame. I was thinking classical guitar might be a good choice, but then I read that classical guitarists need to keep their nails long and constantly care for them. I'm a girl and would need to be doing housework like washing dishes/cooking, and getting my hands wet would be detrimental to fingernails Oh well, maybe it's time to consider flute....or should I dare try the violin??

Basia: Nice to hear from someone playing both flute and piano! Can I ask what are the similarities between both instruments (though they are very diff. from each other!) and what makes learning flute easy/hard? Also, how much does a good beginner flute cost?

Oh, what a difficult question, Marimorimo! Let's see...

Flute is portable, which is great. The large difference between piano and flute, I think, is that piano is a chord instrument. That is, you play several notes at a time at the piano, and just a single note at a time at the flute. This means that flute usually sounds best if you have some kind accompainment, or if you play duetts for example.

A super plus with the flute is that you do not move around the hands in the same way as on a piano, and consequently the fingering is so much easier to learn. Sightreading is a lot easier!

I cannot sing at all, and the flute is an excellent substitute. I feel I can express music differently then on a piano, have a different control of the tone. Flute is a more personal instrument to me.

The piano is on the other hand excellent when it comes to help us understand theory and to visualise music. There is almost no limit for what you can do musically on a piano, after a lot of study at least.

About learning. It is much easier to self-teach piano then flute. No matter if you wish to continue with lessons or not, it's a good idea to have a good teacher help you out at the beginning.

Don't worry if you can't get a sound the first time you try. It is all about blowing so that the air hits the hole (exactly!) at the right spot. According to me, the basics are easy to learn, but then you can work for ages trying to improve the sound. You'll practise breathing correctly so that you have good air support, practise adjusting embrouchre (how to shape the lips when blowing) so that you get a better tone and so that you can adjust the pitch so that you can stay in tune when playing with others. On flute small details can make a big difference in sound.

The things that you have learnt on the piano will make learning any new instrument easier. For example rythm and general music reading.

Flute can be used in different music styles such as classical and jazz, so it should not be a problem if you would like to try something new sometime.

Here is nice site with plenty of flute information for all levels:
http://www.jennifercluff.com/articles.htm

I think there are other (more experienced?) flute players around here, so please correct me if you have additional information.

My thoughts exactly!


PS: ¿Hablas español, Marimorimo?

Thank you so much for that informative post, Basia! One thing that concerns me about flutes and violins is if they'll sound good solo (I don't know of any musicians who will accompany me and I have no intention of playing in an ensemble). Though I did see a youtube video of an extremely good solo flute player and it totally blew my mind. I can't sing at all, too! That's why I'm trying to uncover some musicality by trying out instruments

I was also wishing for something more portable unlike the piano.... if I can't make up my mind, I just might end up with a recorder or a penny whistle myself!




No..ya no hablo español He olvidado todo... Pero lo entiendo un poco.

Perdona los errores.

Hey, that's pretty pretty good!


Back on topic,
Celtic Harp is also a good option or even Cello. Not as portable as a violin or flute, but still easier to carry with you than a piano.

The saxophone.
Pick-up an alto, which is probably the easiest to play. It's very portable, about the size of a violin case.
The clarinet is a good portable option also, but in my opinion, the alto is easier to play. And the sound more hip.
If you haven't played them before, they are very challenging. Good tone production is key.
The downside is that these instruments are expensive.

If you want to play solo with no accompaniment of any kind, then the guitar is probably your only serious option.

As far as ultimate portability, the chromatic harmonica is good also. But I warn you, it's a very difficult instrument to play. You don't use your hands except for the one button on the side. So finding notes can be quite tricky.

I think you'll be surprised at how difficult these instruments are, compared to the piano (except the guitar).
Have fun!

Hm, most of the intruments will sound more interesting with some kind of accompaniment. I agree with Knotty about the guitar.

However, you can always record your own accompaniment om piano since you play it. And there is much sheet music that includes a cd with background music in case you want it. I wouldn't worry too much about it, since you will likely find people to play with if you notice you want to later.

Is there a possibility you could try some different instruments out (with someone showing you how)? I think you should choose by your heart, and consider in what context you would like to play one day. After all, you will be spending a lot of time listening to yourself practising.

Now I'm getting curious about what the end result will be! Have fun!

I vote for guitar. It's portable, easy to learn, especially with the right teacher, if you like to sing, it's great for that and most of the sheet music you buy for songs has guitar/piano/voice.

There's also a very neat feature at musicnotes.com, where you get 2 free software programs to read and listen to the sheet music you buy. You get something called Guitar Guru, which gives you a graphic of the guitar playing the music. Not to mention all the guitar lessons on Utube etc..

I took a guitar class at the junior college with my daughter and the teacher is phenomenal. He has taught us riffs, songs, theory, a classical piece, finger-picking, strumming, all in a few weeks.

Knotty : I had to look up youtube to know exactly what a saxophone was. It's nice, but I get the impression that's it's more suited for pop or jazz, and though those would be nice to play, I prefer more classical-sounding music. I love listening to background theme music from various soundtracks So which woodwind instruments are suited for classical music? Flute?? Oboe??

Nikalette : I also think the guitar is the best bet. I like Spanish and Flamenco style guitar music. Are those played with the classical guitar? What holds me back, though, is the need for nail maintenance! Doing housework (getting my hands wet) is detrimental to fingernails which are an essential in playing guitar How do guitarists cope with this?

Basia C. : I'm afraid it's probably still a long way off before I make the final decision (as of now I have my hands full with piano), but I'll let you know when I do decide eventually


I never thought it would be so hard to choose an instrument! I've ALWAYS wanted to play piano so it wasn't a hard decision when I took it up last May on a whim My second choice of instrument will not be made on a whim, so I'd like to think it over carefully...

Since all of the instruments have their pros and cons, as well as being expensive, I'm starting to think of taking up voice instead I have no delusions of becoming a soloist or even joining a choir. I just want to be able to sing something in tune!. I can't sing! LOL. But somehow, singing embarrasses me

You can forget about the oboe, unless you are seriously committed. It has to be the most difficult instrument to play. It uses double reeds that are hand made by the musician. Although at first, your teacher would probably make them for you.

Your idea of the saxophone is correct.
The clarinet is well suited to classical. Its sounds is much lighter than the saxohone. It's a fun, but difficult instrument.

go with the guitar. Very cheap on craigslist

++

I play violin and classical guitar. Your nails shouldn't actually be very long to play classical guitar. There is actualy an ideal length (varies from person to person based on the shape of your fingers) that allows you to attack the string just where the nail meets the skin without creating a bunch of extra noise. I keep my nails filed, and then I go back over the nail edges with very fine sand paper. I have never had a nail break unless I let my nails get longer or uneven, and since I'm not a professional musician, I didn't particularly avoid any other activities in order to maintain my nails.

The one thing that does look a bit odd is that for both violin and guitar, the nails on the left hand must be kept very short so they don't interfere with pressing down the strings.

Too much to learn not enough time, that's the biggest issue here. Just started learning the piano, but I think I also want to consider learning to play the guitar in a year or so time, as it looks very appealing and I think I have the time to devote to two instruments. First though I want to progress ahead with the piano and get decent at it. Just a rather quick question about the guitar, is there any major differences in learning to play the guitar as a left handed? All I know is that you have to get a left handed guitar, but is there anything else to it?

Then again, I really also want to learn to make music with the computer and such, who knows if ill ever get the time to do that but it sounds like so much fun but I think that's quite a bit ahead, if ever.

It´s not as difficult as you might think. After a year of piano lessons from not knowing anything about music before that, I decided to pick up the viola. It´s true that notation for viola is in a different clef, but all in all, it hasn´t been extremely difficult for me.

Actually, you´ll find out when you pick up a second instrument (particularly if this instrument is melodic), that it´s actually much easier than piano since you´ll only be reading one clef, and you´ll have the rhythm pretty much figured out. Sure, every instrument has it´s own easy and hard aspects, and in viola position is kind of the big deal you have to learn to acquire and dominate, but it´s doable with enough practice and patience, as you might have figured out with piano by now.

My best bet would be that, if you want it badly enough, pick up an instrument you love the sound of. And don´t worry about practice time, if you really want to learn them, you´ll find the time for both.

Always remember to put down the piano first before attempting to pick up anything else. Pianos tend to be quite heavy!

Maybe Monica can come by and lend you an accordion to try out...