Some may not like her because of the way she dresses...but she certainly has the chops.

I don't feel qualified to judge Lola's technical ability, but I would be interested to know what those who are qualified think of her playing ability, apart for the controversial stylistic elements. In other words, if qualified piano contest judges just heard an audio of her playing, or a video of just her hands playing, what would they say? I thought about starting a separate topic to ask that question, but I don't want to start another fight about whether she's a circus act. Maybe I'll do it anyway at some point, and let the moderators deal with the mud slinging.

Oops, I just realized I posted a similar post in this thread already. I won't delete this one, maybe it being repeated will cause someone to give their opinion. (about her PLAYING)

Such a heated debate, I even felt compelled to jump right in the middle. I think the source of animosity seems to be Lola's controversial artistic style, which I think is genuine. I have her CD where as you say there are no visuals, just the sound. So far I am immensely impressed, her Chopin seems to have a golden tone that is a rarity, and yes, it reminded me of you know who (Horwitzian will surely know) I love her phrasing, her detailed use of pedal and I think her technique is on the money. I personally like the eccentric movements and think that it's fascinating and refreshing to watch her. Most pianists don't move as much, but hey everyone is different. What some have referred to as "circus" act I think is genuine expression. With Lang Lang I don't feel that what his does comes from within. I can't explain why but when I watch and listen to him I feel that his "faces" are made for the sake of being showy, and his "emotions" are dishonest and not a reflection of him feeling the music. That makes me question him as an artist. However I feel differently about Lola's theatrics. I "buy" her showmanship for some reason. I feel that it's honest. Just my two cents.

Indeed I do, and that's why I think she's excellent. Other than that she's a babe.

I've already stated how I feel, but I wonder how many would feel differently about her if she were a man. How many would feel differently if Lang were a woman? My sentiments wouldn't change at all, but I'm curious.
I do hope, in response to the two posts above this one, that neither of you are comparing her to, arguably, the greatest pianist to ever walk upon the face of this earth.

No one said she was better.

Oh I know (and thank God). I just am a little repulsed that she'd even be mentioned in the same breath (then again I don't mention many OTHER pianists in the same breath).

Look, I'm sorry you don't have as high opinion of her playing as others, but you've made your point at least twice.

FYI, don't expect me to become LolaAstanovian anytime soon.