This is probably a topic that comes up often, but I was unable to find any existing threads that discussed the subject.

I've decided to begin taking private lessons in the new year. As a result, I need to choose a teacher and was hoping to solicit input on what kinds of things I should be thinking about as I make my selection.

Thoughts?

I think most important is that you are comfortable with the person. Obviously they should be knowledgeable and be able to communicate well enough. Perhaps give it a few lessons and then decide if you like them. If you can, talk to students who have had lessons in the past with the instructor and perhaps ask them specific questions. Once you have an instructor make sure you outline your goals so that they can help you work towards them.

Thank you for your input.

Mostly what I've been considering is the kind of music I'd like to play. Like most people, I enjoy a variety of music: jazz, classical, and a some new-age stuff too.

I've also been thinking that it will be important to know what experience the instuctor has in working with adult students (as I am one) as opposed to working with children/younger students.

A few years back, I took a Group Piano class at my local community college. All adult-beginners. There were multiple levels of students in the class together. That was good for the first semester when I was essentially among the entry level students. But after that, I didn't find I was getting the attention I would have liked. The woman who ran the class was great though, and I'm pretty sure she offers private instruction as well. And since I'm already pretty comfortable with her, I might go in that direction.

Yeah, I think there are a couple problems with the piano class idea. One you already mentioned in that it's important to have someone who can work one on one with you and really focus on you. The other is that you are moving at a fixed pace with the class and if you want to speed it up or slow it down in terms of progress then there is really no point to the class. I guess it's nice to make friends with people in the class who also have piano as an interest but the is probably one of the only benefits. Other than that, I recommend a personal instructor all the way.

Personally, I really like the teacher I have now. We seem to mix pretty well personality wise and it makes the lessons a joy!

The best indicators of a good teacher is how long they've been doing it, how many students they currently have, and how skilled they're own playing is. Ask the teachers you're interested in three things:
1. How long have you been teaching?
2. How many students do you have that are at or around the same level I am?
3. Can you play me something that you feel show's off your personal proficiency on the piano?

Any teacher worth their rate should be able to provide you with satisfactory answers to each question, if not, keep looking.

If you can, try and hire someone you've been referred to by a friend. This way you know some history on the teacher, and you're friend can hopefully give you an honest review of their skill.

Regarding #3...Being able to play well is an important component of teaching, but never an indication that the person is good teacher.

Playing well, and teaching well are two completely different skills.

A better indicator of a good teacher is a roster of students who can play well, and who rave about the teacher.