Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums Over 2 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!
Neat sites! But they gave me five incorrect answers in a row.
The first one gave me zero.
The second gave me mostly non-classical even though I specified "classical" and it said "classical." But BTW most of the classical things it gave were Beethoven, although none of them really resembled what we've got here.
I have a feeling the OP gave the wrong notes. Beethoven doesn't do A minor very often.
I wouldn't consider that "the wrong notes." I never assumed it was being given in the exact key, nor that the OP was trying to do that. I actually consider it sort of standard to give 'unknown' melodies in C major or minor (which is what the "Dictionary of Musical Themes" does) or A minor.
Itay, can we ask: Where do you think you got it, and how do you know it's exactly that? (Or at least very close.) I think we've all had instances where we've misremembered a melody, in varying degrees. For example, a while back, I asked about a phrase that was stuck in my mind, and I was pretty sure I had it right but in fact I had one of the harmonies wrong. (Beet314 was able to give the answer anyway.)
I'm latching on to a Bagatelle, but I have no idea which one. It just sounds like it might be one. Probably not by Beethoven, though, since I don't think he wrote any in A-minor. Any of the experts have a clue?
I can tell you I've never seen or heard this piece before based on the OP's rendition of the notes they remember.
OP- do you no longer have the sheet music for it anywhere in the house? Do you remember if you played it out of a book, or off a photocopy? (Book would be better.. I'd ask if you remember what book?)
Every day we are afforded a new chance. The problem with life is not that you run out of chances. In the end, what you run out of are days.
....Probably not by Beethoven, though, since I don't think he wrote any in A-minor....
Remember, he never said it was in that key. (And even if it was given in A minor in that study book, it wouldn't mean much.)
A couple of other posters took the key sort of seriously, and I think that's a mistake with things like this, including because often there is no attempt or intent to duplicate the actual key -- including in reference books.
Loc: Victoria, BC
Originally Posted By: Derulux
I'm latching on to a Bagatelle, but I have no idea which one. It just sounds like it might be one. Probably not by Beethoven, though, since I don't think he wrote any in A-minor. Any of the experts have a clue? [...]
I did go through all of the Beethoven "Bagatellen" not searching for A minor but searching for the theme as posted by the OP, but did not find anything resembling the theme he played. Won't I be embarrassed if it turns out to be a Bagatelle?
BruceD - - - - - Estonia 190 in satin ebony
Won't I be embarrassed if it turns out to be a Bagatelle?
I don't think you'd be the first one here to be embarrassed.
BTW, looking up those notes in "Dictionary of Musical Themes" (transposed to C minor, as is needed), the closest examples are by Vivaldi and Frescobaldi. I don't mean I think it's by one of them -- those examples clearly aren't it. Just sayin'.