Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums Over 3 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments. Over 100,000 members from around the world.
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
(it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!
I have the opposite problem. I've spent so much of my time on solo piano that it comes much easier to me than combo. It's a different kind of playing though since it's mosty two handed voicings.
The difficulty for me in solo jazz playing is implying the rhythm at all times. I don't particularly like too much rubato playing so I don't do that. But if it's not a ballad, I can't always imply a good groove. Something I've got to improve on.
I tend to play it more like classical. More play on dynamics and such. Teacher's influence
I have a solo piano gig on Sunday. Formal event. Cocktail hour playing.
I also see he used Fsus7 F7 instead of Cm7 F7. Pretty typical sub.
Yes, but really I should have put the bass line in also, because the Standard Trio's greatness does depend all their independent voices playing together, and their interplay is amazing. PDF with the first 16 bars again, this time with bass Check out how they interplay.
For those of you interested, here's the midi file (from Finale) N.B: this will sound with straight 8's unless you can change your 'swing' setting.
Audio rendered within Finale (yes Finale has cheesy sounds, yes I have access to a horrendous amount of sample libraries, but I prefer the internal sounds whilst working in Finale, it focuses my mind on the content and not the groovy sounds of my 30 Gb piano)
You're quite a resource here. Very nice! Thanks!
So actually that Cm7 was just a Fourths voicing now. Listening to Finale made be realize that he syncopated the melody. That wasn't that obvious to me just reading the score.
Lot's of work transcribing here...
Listening to it emphasized the fact the voicings themselves weren't too unusual.
Talking about solo piano, at one of our jams, the pianist played a very complex solo piano intro to Stella before going into combo. I noticed a lot of players do this so it's something I'd like to do too.
Scott, I didn't realize there was more music on your site. I just discovered that I had to scroll down
Listening to My Favorite things. This is solo piano and you have a good sense of time because the pulse didn't disappear for a millisecond. That was excellent.
You're right about the expectations of technique in Jazz. And maybe because Monk got away with purposely playing with his typical rough style that that has been an approach by many although I think it's also an excuse for some.
I think the newer Jazz pianists are collectively more like "pianists" than "piano players" now. Maybe it's because most had Classical training. I myself have only been playing piano for 6 years so there's still technique building needed. But I'm always sensitive to thinking about the technique aspect as a goal.
I understand completely what Chris is talking about because my teacher plays with a touch that fits that exact mode he describes. His LH is buttery and his RH always has an intentional tone that makes the melody or solo line sing. It's really a fantastic goal to work on. Sometimes as jazzers, we seek the fast playing stuff. But the nice tone on the solo is the other aspect that's equally satisfying.
I have the opposite problem. I've spent so much of my time on solo piano that it comes much easier to me than combo. It's a different kind of playing though since it's mosty two handed voicings.
The difficulty for me in solo jazz playing is implying the rhythm at all times. I don't particularly like too much rubato playing so I don't do that. But if it's not a ballad, I can't always imply a good groove. Something I've got to improve on.
I tend to play it more like classical. More play on dynamics and such. Teacher's influence
I have a solo piano gig on Sunday. Formal event. Cocktail hour playing.
Hey, why not post some solo stuff for us here? I don't recall any solo piano that you've done. Did I miss it?
And on another topic: Does anyone here play Beatrice? If so, has anyone seen the chart that has the Em A7 to Dmaj in it? I'm wondering because I've never played it with a Dmaj7 anywhere in the tune, but this guy I recently played with has this. I've listened to the original recording (Fuchsia Swing album) and I don't believe there is a Dmaj in there. I can't say that I don't like it, but was just wondering where this chord may have come from. Link to clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxMIiTW59Co
Last edited by scepticalforumguy; 01/13/1102:00 AM. Reason: I can't spell properly.
Recordings of my recent solo piano and piano/keyboard trio jazz standards.
I've posted a lot of things playing solo but I wouldn't call it solo piano style. Most of what I posted was with an imagined rhythm section. Nef would be a nice challenge. It's hard for me to keep a groove going on that.
I don't know Beatrice, but for some reason I recollect Chris Bell playing that. But I may be confusing some other female names for tunes.
It would be great if somehow all tried to play some common tunes so we can share in the ideas. We can give a shot at Blue Monk too, now that Scott has that as a contribution to the fray. I don't want to give up on the Blues idea because that's actually hard for me.
Hey I don't mind the challenges but don't leave me to do it alone because then it's boring. If I'm going to screw up, it's best to do it alone
I'll start posting a recording soon. Maybe another stab at Stella tomorrow.
And on another topic: Does anyone here play Beatrice? If so, has anyone seen the chart that has the Em A7 to Dmaj in it? I'm wondering because I've never played it with a Dmaj7 anywhere in the tune, but this guy I recently played with has this. I've listened to the original recording (Fucsia Swing album) and I don't believe there is a Dmaj in there. I can't say that I don't like it, but was just wondering where this chord may have come from. Link to clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxMIiTW59Co
Does anyone here play Beatrice? If so, has anyone seen the chart that has the Em A7 to Dmaj in it? I'm wondering because I've never played it with a Dmaj7 anywhere in the tune, but this guy I recently played with has this. I've listened to the original recording (Fucsia Swing album) and I don't believe there is a Dmaj in there. I can't say that I don't like it, but was just wondering where this chord may have come from. Link to clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxMIiTW59Co
I've seen that chart, but have never played it with a Dmaj7. It is there on that recording, though, in passing to Dm, at 0:38-0:39. You can hear the movement from F# to F-nat. The Dmaj7 lasts for only about 0.5sec.
And on another topic: Does anyone here play Beatrice? If so, has anyone seen the chart that has the Em A7 to Dmaj in it? I'm wondering because I've never played it with a Dmaj7 anywhere in the tune, but this guy I recently played with has this. I've listened to the original recording (Fucsia Swing album) and I don't believe there is a Dmaj in there. I can't say that I don't like it, but was just wondering where this chord may have come from. Link to clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxMIiTW59Co
Very nice tune. Looks easy enough to learn.
You'd be surprised. Listen to the clip again. If you know the changes, you'll also hear that Jaki Byard doesn't know them too well. I imagine this might have been a case where the composer (Sam Rivers) maybe wanted to record this piece and put it in front of the players at the session? I really don't know, but to me it sounds like but Byard is just soloing over the changes Fmaj/Gb+4, Dmin/Ebmaj and Amin/Bbmaj in ways that don't lead to each other very well, but Sam has obviously blown over the changes a few times so makes things make real sense.
But yes, it seems like a pretty straight forward tune when you looks at it initially.
You're also right about Chris playing this (and quite well too). I believe he actually may have played the Dmaj chord that I'm talking about too, that's what made me think that there might be another version that Sam recorded that I haven't heard that has that chord in there.
Last edited by scepticalforumguy; 01/13/1102:14 AM. Reason: clarified what 'soloing' rather than 'played the changes'
Recordings of my recent solo piano and piano/keyboard trio jazz standards.
I've seen that chart, but have never played it with a Dmaj7. It is there on that recording, though, in passing to Dm, at 0:38-0:39. You can hear the movement from F# to F-nat. The Dmaj7 lasts for only about 0.5sec.
Ya, but it's not used by the soloists at any time is it? I thought I heard a passing note in that sequence at :39 too, but on the second time in the head and on the head going out and the rest of the Sam's solos there is a Dsus or Dmin there, except for one time at 2:12 again.
I do like the Dmaj though it gives it a really different colour than what you'd expect to hear there.
Recordings of my recent solo piano and piano/keyboard trio jazz standards.
Hey I don't mind the challenges but don't leave me to do it alone because then it's boring. If I'm going to screw up, it's best to do it alone
Huh? Do want company or don't you? Or are you suggesting that you will screw up if we don't play it with you? Or...?
In any case, I'm game for doing some tunes together. I'm still looking into BiG, Stella and I'd actually like to hear other people play Beatrice just because I've been wondering if anyone would come up with different voicings for solo piano than I would.
Also, JW, I do now remember your 'solo' recordings, but they don't count because as you said you were playing with an imagined rhythm section. So, I'd like to hear the stuff you'd do for your Sunday gig. Bring along your H4 and record yourself.
Recordings of my recent solo piano and piano/keyboard trio jazz standards.
Sunday gig? -- no, I'm not going to record that. Fortunately it's not exposed playing. But it's an awfully regulated Steinway. I'd probably have tendonitis after. And I'm lucky if they tuned it since last time.
OK so we have a lot of stuff to work on. Great.
Did you change the words on my post? I thought I wrote it "was best to do it as a group". That was weird...
Hey Scep, it's these challenges that make me learn so I tend to go for the more difficult tunes and less on the 'How High the Moon' stuff. So if I like it, I will have a tendency to stick with it for awhile like I have with Nef and Giant Steps.
I've worked on something similar to this. The chromatic movements remind me of Along Came Betty (Benny Golson)
You're also right about Chris playing this (and quite well too).
Thanks.
Quote
I believe he actually may have played the Dmaj chord that I'm talking about too, that's what made me think that there might be another version that Sam recorded that I haven't heard that has that chord in there.
Oh no no no no! Never a Dmaj7 there. (now suddenly not so sure, goes and listens to his own playing . . ) Oh. I did. Sorry. So first time through I played a F# C (D7) going from E7 (instead of the Em7(b5) to A7 to D7 (something I picked up from KJ. Second through the melody I play a . . . Dmaj7. Oh well, just shows you.
but for the record, I don't approve of that chord there, I feel it kills the tune and I promise I will never play a Dmaj7 there again.
I just uploaded two videos of Stella I made this morning. (see below) The first is just the head. I've been trying out some block chords and a rubato approach. Not sure if I like it though.
The second video is just improv. I've been trying to incorporate triad pairs in my lines. It holds together pretty well for about a minute and then I lose it. Oh well!
Beatrice is a nice tune. I used to play it with the Ron Baxter 4tet. I'll get into again and see what I can come up with.