Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums Over 3 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments. Over 100,000 members from around the world.
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers
(it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!
Other Beethoven pieces I play more or less well: Für Elise does this really belong in this list?, third movement of op.57 (Appassionata), and sometimes orchestral pieces. How do you play those on the piano?
My favorite piano concerto of his is the first (op.15, C major). This I can't understand. Over the 4th and 5th?? As for the symphonies, 7 is probably my favorite, with 5, 8 and 3 also great. And no 9th?
Definitely. It's not too challenging technically, but musically. And it's fun to play.
Quote
and sometimes orchestral pieces. How do you play those on the piano?
By ear. I retain the melodies, the core harmonies, and try to play it so it sounds ok. Examples: 1st movement of 7th symphony; Egmont overture; violin concerto.
Quote
My favorite piano concerto of his is the first (op.15, C major). This I can't understand. Over the 4th and 5th??
Yes. In fact, the 4th and 5th are my least favorite piano concertos of his. I don't think they're bad; I just don't care much for them.
Quote
As for the symphonies, 7 is probably my favorite, with 5, 8 and 3 also great. And no 9th?
A few weeks ago, there was a thread about ranking Beethoven's symphonies. My reply was: 7 5 8 3 9 1 6 4 2. So 9 is just around the corner.
My grand piano is a Yamaha C2 SG. My other Yamaha is an XMAX 300.
and sometimes orchestral pieces. How do you play those on the piano?
By ear. I retain the melodies, the core harmonies, and try to play it so it sounds ok. Examples: 1st movement of 7th symphony; Egmont overture; violin concerto.
Why not learn an actual transcription?
Originally Posted by patH
Quote
My favorite piano concerto of his is the first (op.15, C major). This I can't understand. Over the 4th and 5th??
Yes. In fact, the 4th and 5th are my least favorite piano concertos of his. I don't think they're bad; I just don't care much for them.
Why bother? Even a good transcription usually doesn't sound as good as the orchestral version. At least to me. So the benefit of having just a slightly better version is not really worth the effort of learning something by score instead of by ear. And when I play pop music, I almost always play by ear. When the harmonies are not too difficult, it's easier for me than sight playing.
My grand piano is a Yamaha C2 SG. My other Yamaha is an XMAX 300.
Pat I understand you- I think it is an achievement that you play some Beethoven by ear! I have just started pianoforall tonight and am pleased with it so far.Robin's method is chords based with some notation. I recieved a book about Ludwig and Josephine Brunswick this morning from Amazon.I feel so sorry for them that they could not get married. The stress of it made Josephine ill.
This is a great thread and one that was long overdue.
For those of you who subscribe to Netflix Instant Streaming there is a great documentary on Beethoven entitled "Searching for Beethoven". I have watched it 2x and learned quite a lot about the man and his music.
Beethoven batting list (all comparatively easy for beginners)
Fur Elise (for learning arpeggios - like a harp) Minuet in G (charming ... and only three pages) (became the theme for the sitcom Fawlty Towers!) Pathetique Sonata Opus 13 (soulful) Moonlight Sonata Opus 27, no. 2 (easy opening 2 measures) Les Adieu Opus 81a (sheer poetry)
Great thread! I love Beethoven. And when life gets hard, I seem to want to immerse myself in his piano sonatas. Right now I’m trying to memorize the 3rd movement of the Moonlight sonata (27/2), which is way out of my league but I’m having loads of fun working on it. I’ve also been listening a lot to the 3rd movement of the Op. 109 Sonata. It’s way too difficult for me to play, but I’ve printed off the first page with the theme and first variation. They are beautiful and slow, and I like to try to play through them.
Here are two books I enjoyed about Beethoven (I already mentioned them previously on this site, but might as well list them here in this thread!) They were written by actual friends of Beethoven, and because of this I think they are real treasures:
Memories of Beethoven: From the House of the Black-Robed Spaniards by Gerhard von Breuning (the personal notes of a man who was close to Beethoven as a child)
Beethoven Remembered: The Biographical Notes of Franz Wegeler and Ferdinand Ries by Wegeler and Ries (recollections of Beethoven by his long-time friends)
Not sure which of Beethoven’s pieces would be accessible to beginners. But we had a list of his sonata movements suitable for intermediate players in this thread:
Some of the pieces that are achievable for "late beginners" there are the ecossaises. I think I did learn the WoO 83 when I was in single digit age ... good times :-)
Great thread! I love Beethoven. And when life gets hard, I seem to want to immerse myself in his piano sonatas.
He'd love that Valencia- he had such a difficult life and sought to bring comfort to everyone with his music. Did you know he sued to play for friends if they were ill or upset? I LOVE his sonatas- they are my favourite music of his and in fact of all music I have heard.
Quote
Right now I’m trying to memorize the 3rd movement of the Moonlight sonata (27/2), which is way out of my league but I’m having loads of fun working on it.
Good for you!
Quote
I’ve also been listening a lot to the 3rd movement of the Op. 109 Sonata. It’s way too difficult for me to play, but I’ve printed off the first page with the theme and first variation. They are beautiful and slow, and I like to try to play through them.
Oh those variations- they are so sublime they make me euphoric listening to them.
Quote
Here are two books I enjoyed about Beethoven (I already mentioned them previously on this site, but might as well list them here in this thread!) They were written by actual friends of Beethoven, and because of this I think they are real treasures:
Memories of Beethoven: From the House of the Black-Robed Spaniards by Gerhard von Breuning (the personal notes of a man who was close to Beethoven as a child)
Beethoven Remembered: The Biographical Notes of Franz Wegeler and Ferdinand Ries by Wegeler and Ries (recollections of Beethoven by his long-time friends)
I haven't read those but I expect some of these will be in a book I have called Beethoven, Impressions by his Contemporaries. They reveal a fascinating, kind person despite the plate throwing lol.
I'm reading a book by John Klapporth about Ludwig and Josephine Brunsvik -the lady who I am sure was the Eternal Beloved. It is very tragic- she eventually died of a broken heart because her mother would not let her marry Ludwig.
Some of the pieces that are achievable for "late beginners" there are the ecossaises. I think I did learn the WoO 83 when I was in single digit age ... good times :-)
there are section quite tricky for beginners ( double thirds and double sixts.. but being in small burst is a good introduction to that technique ).
after writing about it I feel a massive urge to put it under the fingers again! back to practice.
I must listen to them- I am quite excited Ataru, as although I have liked Beethoven's music for about 4 years, it is only recently, since doing the Coursera course about his sonatas that I have come to fully appreciate his genius and now love his music more than anyone's! I have so much to discover of his music- he wrote loads of it! Life without Beethoven would be no life at all.
Don’t dumb down chaps ... even if “skeerdy cats†(thank you for that Mark Twain) ... Michael 99 and Polyphonist have ducked for cover on my suggestions ...
Fur Elise (for learning arpeggios - like a harp) Minuet in G (charming ... and only three pages) (became the theme for the sitcom Fawlty Towers!) Pathetique Sonata Opus 13 (soulful) Moonlight Sonata Opus 27, no. 2 (easy opening 2 measures) Les Adieu Opus 81a (sheer poetry)
Fur Elise is 70% a piece of cake learning arpeggios ,,, the 2 tricky internal bits can be left till later. For the rest, a slow and dedicated application, will pay off in confidence gained ... with Beethoven masterpieces in your current repertoire.
I always recommend the first movement of Fur Elise for beginners. It's not too hard to learn and it sounds beautiful. Here is a video of me playing the whole piece:
Minuet in G (charming ... and only three pages) (became the theme for the sitcom Fawlty Towers!)
I wish you hadn't told me that- I went on you tube and typed in the minuet, I will now have trouble listening to this minuet seriously.... I wonder if John Cleese was aware of Dennis Wilson being inspired by Beethoven to write the theme music? Basil Fawlty had this weird German obsession. And his hotel is as bad as the ones Beethoven was unfortunate to get served in. Imagine Ludwig meeting Basil!!! And Manuel would have had to duck had Beethoven patronised Fawlty Towers!
Quote
Fur Elise is 70% a piece of cake learning arpeggios ,,, the 2 tricky internal bits can be left till later. For the rest, a slow and dedicated application, will pay off in confidence gained ... with Beethoven masterpieces in your current repertoire.
When one is a plonky fumbly fingered beginner nothing is a piece of cake...
I always recommend the first movement of Fur Elise for beginners. It's not too hard to learn and it sounds beautiful. Here is a video of me playing the whole piece:
I hope some of you take advantage of this (everything is free).
Steve- I have just completed your first tutorial! I found the Fur Elise sheet music from one of my books and was looking at it on my lap to refer to as watched the video. I paused at each bit and played it on my old Cecil. I found the E- E stretch a bit far at first ( got very little hands) but as kept on with it my hand seemed to flex more.I even did the pedalling! Thanks I shall keep practising it and then go to the next tutorial. i really LOVED that.