Piano World Home Page Forums Our Most Popular Forums Pianist Corner Playing fluid scales

I always enjoy hearing scales played smoothly and evenly, for example in the music of Mozart. I've never been able to reliably produce this effect but lately I stumbled across a technique that seems to work: simply keep the wrist low. For some reason, that facilitates passing the thumb which helps to keep scales fluid over multiple octaves.
Does anyone here feel the same way?

Have you tried thumb over? I like it. It works especially if there is speed involved. Thinking about it, thumb under rotates the hand and forearm so that the thumb side of the hand is in more of a down position than the outer part of the hand/arm. Then then forefinger and others are not positioned over the next set of keys. The really fast adjustment to keep the speed just doesn't work for me, never has. I also find with thumb over, my fingers, hand and arm are much more relaxed and ready to strike. Thumb under is necessary for most legato playing, especially if it is in a slower section.

Adding: Thumb over is probably a bad description, since it sounds like the wrist/hand is turned so the thumb is at the top or maybe not quite that far up. It's the slight lifting of the forearm/hand/fingers and lateral movement that makes the difference.

This is funny, because when I first started learning on my own (2 years ago now almost, then I switched jobs and had to take a break before resuming with a teacher) I learned through the internet's infinite wisdom that scales were the way to go. Scales scales scales. Gotta go fast! HOW do I go fast? THUMB OVER! So I sat there rotating my wrist so that the thumb literally went over, and I looked ridiculous. Then I found a youtube video describing the technique and showing roughly how its used and declaring it "thumb next too" because ultimately at speed the thumb gently comes next to the #2 finger and wrist rotation gives the "over" part of the name. I have now quickly learned with the help of my teacher that I am nowhere near that stage of technique and ability so I've slowed down considerably so as not to ingrain poor technique to iron out later.

I realize this adds little to the thread, but I'm curious for more replies and thought I'd give my anecdotal experience!