How you you tell the difference in pain that is just muscles in the wrist & forearm being worked and what is bad pain, i.e., CTS or tendonitis? When I play fast music or fast scales my wrists and forearms begin to tire and hurt slightly. I think it's just the exercise of the muscles, so I haven't been concerned, but should I be?

Thanks.

Patti

Patti,

I would think that the pains to worry about are the ones that persist after you've finished practicing. I often feel fatigue and pain in my hands and fingers, especially when extending my relatively small hands for chords and arpeggios an octave or more. However when I finish playing, it generally subsides. I think that if you are practicing frequently enough, these muscles will develop.
On the other hand (pardon the pun), every time I use my computer mouse, I get this dull ache in my wrist, which I think is more of a repetitive strain problem, as it starts as soon as I use it, and generally does not go away until some time after.
I thinnk this is the difference between something that you just need to work on, and something to worry about.

Jamie

A symptom of carpal tunnel syndrome is numbness, isn't it? I relative of mine had this and it was diagnosed by electrical analysis of nerves.

Does your piano have a heavy action?

i don't believe you should ever feel pain when playing the piano. if you do, it is likely due to improper body mechanics. try to get some coaching from an Alexander Technique instructor who can analyze your body mechanics and correct you. There are talented pianists who have had to give up playing because of these problems. Don't ignore them!

Thanks all for your input. The pain does not persist after I stop playing and there’s no numbness.

So Pique, couldn’t muscles in the arms and wrists get worked and sore just like any other muscles? Any pain is bad? There was a discussion here on the Alexander Technique a long while back. I think I saved a web address for it. I’ll take a look. I definitely don’t want to ignore this if it’s problematic.

MacDuff, yes my piano’s action is on the heavy side. I’ve had a Mason & Hamlin BB for about 10 months after having a Kawai upright. I may still be getting used to the heavier action.

Patti

hi patti,
yes, you can get sore from working out your muscles, but i would contend that if that is happening, you are not properly conditioning your muscles to your new, heavier action. this can result in chronic problems.

there are excercises you can do, both on and off the piano, to stregnthen your hands, wrists, and forearms. someone who is knowledgeable should show you these in person and monitor your performance of them. but failing that, i would stop playing just as soon as you start to hurt. don't keep playing!

if your biomechanics are correct, and it is just a matter of adjusting to the new action, you should gradually be able to play longer and longer on your new piano without pain.

but continuing to play when there is pain is not a good thing.

Patti,

I've recently been taking some Alexander Technique and recommend it. They have lot's to offer.

From my personal experience, I've found that discomfort in the lower part of the arm and wrist can sometimes be caused by something not quite right further up, i.e., the elbow, upper arm, or shoulder area.

I'd also like to pass on a few tips I've been given over the years. Since our fingers and wrist are repeatedly used in one direction when practicing and playing, it is beneficial when finished to excercise the muscles in the opposite direction. One thing to do is take the finger tips of one hand with the other and bend the hand backwards--not forcefully, just give it a nice stretch back and let the elbow and shoulders be relaxes when you do this (don't over do it!). Another thing is to take a rubber band and place it around the finger tips and thumb and then open and close the fingers. It's like pumping iron with the fingers. This does not need to be done for very long--just a little bit. Both these excercises are a nice way to counter the uni-directional use of the muscles during practice.

Very useful info given here. I would like to add one more advice. Chopin always reminded his students not to forget to stretch their hands. Just close your fingers slowly and then again slowly open them fully strecthed out (4-5 times).
Rgds,
Hakki.