That was a remark pianist Moritz Rosenthal is alleged to have made upon hearing that fellow pianist Artur Schnabel had been rejected from military service.

Wednesday night my friend Tim and I went to see the Cleveland Institute of Music Orchestra with Conductor Carl Topilow at Severance Hall. It's always a treat to hear them at Severance, since their usual locale, Kulas Hall, tends to be a bit dry acoustically. The usual gang was there: J. S., the dean of Cleveland record collectors, who has been going to Orchestra concerts since the Szell era, and a gaggle of CIM students including D. L., probably the most talented piano student there. J. S. informed me that a cellist from the Cleveland Orchestra is retiring and will not be replaced—budget cutbacks are being felt and the attrition has begun.

The CIM played the first half of the program superbly. Carl Topilow hadn't even waited for the applause to finish before he lanched into a rollicking Maskarade Overture by Nielsen. The orchestra brought sustained pianissimo playing in the Britten Passacaglia from Peter Grimes, and superb ensemble work in one of my favorites, Prokofiev's suite from Lieutenant Kije. The trumpet soloist contributed some fine work, discreetly darting on and off stage for his more distant solos. It is no exaggeration to say that the CIM's kids play at a level that many professional orchestras would envy.

After intermission came the Beethoven Concerto in G Major, my favorite Beethoven Concerto and one of my favorite Concertos in the entire repertoire. The soloist was Jerome Lowenthal, who was greeted with a big publicity splash in Sunday's Plain Dealer. Again, the orchestral contribution was fine. The same can't be said for Lowenthal's playing. During several parts of the first movement, Tim and I looked at each other in alarm. As a whole, the performance was a mis-mash of dropped (not played) notes, wrong notes, awkward phrasing, poor balance between piano and orchestra (entirely the fault of the soloist) and overpedalling to the extent that Beethoven's piano writing was at times incomprehensible. This is a professional pianist? Half the students at CIM could play it better than he did. Indeed, at the 1997 competition several contestants played this very same concerto, and they all did a better job. I've heard about 40 different performances of this concerto, from legendary interpreters such as Kempff and Rubinstein, all the way down to students, but I have never heard the piece sloppily molested as it was last night. (J. S., who has several decades more experience than I, agreed wholeheartedly.) What a disappointment!

About the only point of interest in Lowenthal's performance was the fact that he played a new Cadenza by Rzewski in the first movement and one by Medtner in the last. Rumor has it he's to record the concerto with several different cadenzas, which the listener may choose from, but that would be the only reason to buy this disc.
_________________________
Hank Drake

The composers want performers be imaginative, in the direction of their thinking--not just robots, who execute orders.
George Szell