Welcome to the Piano World Piano Forums
Over 2 million posts about pianos, digital pianos, and all types of keyboard instruments
Join the World's Largest Community of Piano Lovers (it's free)
It's Fun to Play the Piano ... Please Pass It On!

Gifts and supplies for the musician
SEARCH
the Forums & Piano World

This custom search works much better than the built in one and allows searching older posts.
Ad (Piano Sing)
How to Make Your Piano Sing
(ad) Pearl River
Pearl River Pianos
(ad 125) Sweetwater - Digital Keyboards & Other Gear
Digital Pianos at Sweetwater
(ad) Pianoteq
(ad) P B Guide
Acoustic & Digital Piano Guide
Who's Online
133 registered (acoxcae, Anita Potter, AnimistFvR, anamnesis, accordeur, ando, 35 invisible), 1580 Guests and 20 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Quick Links to Useful Piano & Music Resources
Our Classified Ads
Find Piano Professionals-

*Piano Dealers - Piano Stores
*Piano Tuners
*Piano Teachers
*Piano Movers
*Piano Restorations
*Piano Manufacturers
*Organs

Quick Links:
*Advertise On Piano World
*Free Piano Newsletter
*Online Piano Recitals
*Piano Recitals Index
*Piano & Music Accessories
*Music School Listings
* Buying a Piano
*Buying A Acoustic Piano
*Buying a Digital Piano
*Pianos for Sale
*Sell Your Piano
*How Old is My Piano?
*Piano Books
*Piano Art, Pictures, & Posters
*Directory/Site Map
*Contest
*Links
*Virtual Piano
*Music Word Search
*Piano Screen Saver
*Piano Videos
*Virtual Piano Chords
(ad) Estonia Piano
Estonia Pianos
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >
Topic Options
#915721 - 04/26/03 12:53 PM Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
I find it very difficult to read both hands at the same time when the soprano voice is very high and the bass very low.

I did not find a translation of "portee" the five lines one in treble key and bass key.

My question is can you see the two "portees" at the same time or to you scan back and forth
vertically ?



I once had a friend staying over from the USA.
She saw I had a Mozart's sonatas and she just sat down and just played at normal speed and said :
Oh, that's nice. I didn't know that one...

She never knew how close she had escaped death.
\:D
_________________________
Benedict

Top
Sheet Music (Piano World is an Affiliate)
Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale  
#915722 - 04/26/03 03:41 PM Re: Sightreading technique
BruceD Online   content
Yikes! 10000 Post Club Member

Registered: 05/26/01
Posts: 18236
Loc: Victoria, BC
benedict:

The French portée in English is correctly known as "staff" (pl. staves), although some pianists may refer to the right hand staff as the "treble clef" and the left hand staff as the "bass clef".

The secret in learning to sight-read well is to always read as much as a bar ahead of where you are actually playing. Yes, it is possible to read the two staves at the same time.
_________________________
BruceD
- - - - -
Estonia 190

Top
#915723 - 04/27/03 06:39 AM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Thank you Bruce D.
\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915724 - 04/27/03 01:52 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
I have tried to read one bar in advance, but I stopped reading altogether.

I wonder if it is not like reading books. At first, you read one letter at a time, then one "syllabe", then one word, then one part of sentence, then one sentence, then one line etc.

Do you think this advance comes naturally with a lot of practice ?

There is so much joy in sightplaying.
I suppose somebody who is illeterate and that can finally throught hard work and enthusiasm read anything he wants from his newspaper to novels or the words of his favorite cartoons must feel he/she is the king of the world.

I have had seven piano teachers : none of them had a clue about sightplaying. They all emphasized memorizing. I have had to build everything anew on sound basis. It has taken years. But it was worth it.

But I still need advice on specific points.
And encouragement. \:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915725 - 04/27/03 03:06 PM Re: Sightreading technique
Praetorian_AD Offline
500 Post Club Member

Registered: 12/24/01
Posts: 717
Loc: England
 Quote:
Originally posted by benedict:

But I still need advice on specific points.
And encouragement. \:\) [/b]
Go get 'em ben.

Actually, I'm really with you on this one. I'm dead set on improving my sight-reading, I'm just not exactly sure how to. Thing is try to do most is just to hack my way through as many pieces as I can find, no matter the difficulty, adjusting my speed appropriately. I make sure I can play the melody first, then the bass, and whatever chords or else happens to arrive during the course of the read come third. I've no idea how to read more than about a half-bar ahead, though...guess I'll just have to keep trying.

Peter

Top
#915726 - 04/27/03 03:37 PM Re: Sightreading technique
ob1knabe Offline
Full Member

Registered: 01/14/03
Posts: 141
Loc: New Jersey
Benedict--
When we learn to read, much of it is through repetition. Children who experience difficulty are asked to re-read the same book several times until it becomes fluid. Their decoding skills becoming more automatic with practice. For a child who is still developing his/her skill, we would never expect them to read a book on that "emerging" level with pure grace. There will be stumbles. What we will hope for is that the same child can read with greater fluency on a level one or two steps below where he/she is practicing. That builds confidence as well as increased practice in word recognition. As the child increases his/her level of expertise, the ability to read fluently on lower levels also increases. So what is my point? When my daughter takes her Trinity exam in piano, there is a sightreading component. She is never tested on whether she can sightread on the same level for which she has practiced her exam. Her sightreading section is always tested at a level below her performance proficiency. I believe there is a reason for this. If the giants that be who created these exams expected people to sightread at the same level they could perform, that's how the exam would be. Your friend who sat down and just sightread Mozart--no doubt impressive (of course I'm wishing that I could do the same thing!!)--but my guess is her skills were on a level higher than that piece. Likewise, if you approached a piece to sightread that was a level below your ability, my guess is you would do well. I think you are too hard on yourself. How do you do sightreading a piece that is below your performance level? As for encouragement--I think you're the best cowboy around and I'm convinced that you can conquer sightreading!! \:\)

Praetorian--maybe I missed this, but how did you do on your A levels? I hope that everything worked out for you.
_________________________
"A thing of beauty is a joy for ever"
John Keats

Top
#915727 - 04/27/03 03:39 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Praetorian,

Thanks for your encouragement. I have fought that battle so long, I thought I would never win.

I have lately found a method that works very well for me : I use Pischna exercizes (I like it because they go through twelve keys) and I read them.

The key, I have found is the rythm.

I count absolutely every subdivision .
I have the little Pischna and the real thing.
The little Pischna, I count :
One and two and three and four And one
or One ee and ah Two ee and ah Three..

For the big Pischna, it is more trick :
O-ne ee-ee a-and a-a Two so as to place the triple croches (32nd ?).

The result : it liberates my mind from the name and the notes and even looking for them on the keyboard. It sort of creates an automatic pilot mode which improves every day with incredible speed.

I think we should not bother about reading ahead. It certainly comes with practice. A child walks slowly at first and suddenly, he rans and nothing can stop him.

After the Pischna, I have tried to see the result on my sightplaying real pieces.
As my goal is Bach, I started with Ana Magdalena.
I was very happy.
Then the Little Preludes. Great.
Yesterday, I said : enough of the childish stuff, now is time for the real stuff.
And I took my old WTC.
I was happy.

This morning I said : let's see how my method does for a Prelude I do not know.
Since I know C (Prelude and Fugue), I figured the next one should be G major (next in the cycle of fifth).
It is a strange time signature :24/16.
I tried first hands separate.
The result was amazing : I just played. As simply as that.
I tried the soprano voice of the fugue : same.

This is the greatest day of my life : the Well Tempered Clavier is mine for all the years to come.
I feel like Jonathan Livingston Seagull who spent so many years looking for the way to fly higher.
\:\)

And the conversations (often heated) on this forum have helped me incredibly.

So, I guess I will follow your advice and got get them.

I am sure that the method I followed would work miracles for you.
The secret is to train not on the real pieces but like in golf on a practice.
I find Pischna works nicely. They sort of free my conscious mind and let my unconscious mind do the work without effort.

But I will write some exercizes for a beginner friend who asked me to help her.

I think I will use children and folk songs (Sur le Pont d'Avignon, Ah vous dirais je maman..) and do a very progressive (step after step) series using each song and bass line in every of the tones with sharps going up and with flats going down. Like this she will know absolutely all the tonalities without having made the least effort.

I hope this long post gives you food for thought.
\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915728 - 04/27/03 05:08 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Ob1Knabe,

Such a pleasure to read you here.
The two posts crossed.

What you say is so true.

When the piano education is done intelligently, the sightplaying is established till memorization becomes natural. Then there should not be a tremendous difference between sightplaying and playing by memory.

The problem occurs when too much emphasis is made on learning by memory and repetition.
Then the two processes get dichotomized and the trouble start.

I was in that rut and the more I worked hard to play the magnificient pieces my teachers proposed me (Bach, Satie's gnossienne 1), the worst it became though the playing sounded fine.

It took me years to undo everything and I just feel I can start afresh today.
But I had to put everything apart till it made sense.

It made me think of Milton Erikson, a great source of inspiration for me. He suffered from the sequels of poliomelytis and at one point in his life, he had to learn how to walk again.
He said that it was incredibly difficult because he had to organize everything for himself.

I felt the same.

I once had a graduate from Conservatoire National Superieur de Musique de Paris : our highest musical institution.

He took the same book of sonatas by Mozart and played at professional level. And I know he first sightread them.

If the two processes of sightreading and memorizing are intertwined, that is how it should be.

Richter practiced sightreading extensively since he was accompanist for shows. His sightreading and playing were absolutely similar.

In a few months, I probably will understand more about the inner connexion between memory and sightreading. But I feel absolutely sure that sightplaying is a great way to achieve confidence and autonomy.

Not only for cowboys. \:D

I wish you the best Ob1Knabe.
\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915729 - 04/27/03 08:25 PM Re: Sightreading technique
apple* Offline


Registered: 01/01/03
Posts: 19862
Loc: Kansas
Benedict - it seems you always worry about sight reading. You are probably a good sight reader. If you see the 2nd B above middle C enough times you will know exactly where it should be. If you play it enough times you will be able to feel where it is easily. All we need is more time.
_________________________
accompanist/organist.. a non-MTNA teacher to a few

love and peace, Õun (apple in Estonian)

Top
#915730 - 04/27/03 11:28 PM Re: Sightreading technique
piqué Offline
5000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/15/01
Posts: 5484
benedict,
it was a joy reading about your experience and of your overcoming your earlier limitations because of poor training. your story is very much like my own, and my teacher also gave me the gift of learning to rely on rhythm. i hope i will soon experience the progress you describe!
_________________________
piqué

now in paperback:


Grand Obsession: A Piano Odyssey

Top
#915731 - 04/29/03 05:27 AM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Pique,

You will undoubtedly.

Once you have understood that rythm is predominant, you have the tools to progress at your rythm.

This morning, I found that a note has two names :
the name of its place on the keyboard (A4, C#5 etc)
and its rythm name :

Like if it is the fourth sixteenth note its rythm name will be aa (one ee and AA).

My brain is happy to concentrate on the rythm name and not on the keyboard name.

I read the fugue in C minor of WTC 1 this morning.
And instead of playing by memory, the reading process took charge.

The rythm name made everything simple.

And when the reading was less easy, the rythm engine slowed considerably while concentrating on the rythm name.

I hope what I write makes sense to you, Pique.

So that when my reading of the rythm will be correct, the rythm will be correct. I will then (and only then) check with a metronom.

I feel it is important that the natural rythm skill gets confident and sort of...happy to live.

Like a natural dancer.

I sincerely hope this helps.

It is a work in progress. But I sense that like in a childbirth, the most difficult part is over when the head of the baby is out.

And playing Bach is some baby.

\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915732 - 04/29/03 08:37 AM Re: Sightreading technique
BruceD Online   content
Yikes! 10000 Post Club Member

Registered: 05/26/01
Posts: 18236
Loc: Victoria, BC
Does anyone else understand Benedict's concept of rhythm name? I didn't understand a word of it.

If you're going to stop to think about the name (pitch name, rhythm name - whatever)of every note you play before you play it, it's going to take a week to get through a short Mozart sonata!

And what happens when you want to play something "up to speed"?

(confused)
_________________________
BruceD
- - - - -
Estonia 190

Top
#915733 - 04/29/03 09:19 AM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Bruce D

Why don't you ask me ? \:\)

I'll answer anyway.

1°The idea is to NEVER say the pitch name.
If you have difficulties with the pitch names of a particular piece, there is another technique which I can give you if you need it.
Of course, that technique will be used best without the piano so as not to be a problem at all. It is impossible to look for a pitch name and then play the key. This process has to be automatic.

2° The technique of the rythm name is useful only for pianists who do not master sightreading or if a piece is difficult rythmwise.
Take the fugue in C major of WTC 1.
The basic rythm is 16th notes with a difficult that comes from the 32th note which gives it its charm (and which apparently had not been written by JSB but by his son-Wanda Landowska dixit).

If I want to read the rythm of the first bar, here is what I do :
It starts on the upbeat of the first time :

And two and three aa-aa (to give the exact space to the two 32nd notes) four and.

Second bar :
One and ee and aa three ee and aa four ee and aa
(it is no use reading the rythm of the soprano voice)

I hope it is clearer.

Of course, one you can sightplay without any problem, the only reading that is required will be the times : One two three four. And the speed is the speed you feel comfortable with.

After a while, your brain will memorize the whole program without the least effort.

The only investment is starting very slowly
Which is one thing all teachers and musicians agree with.

I'm not there yet, but I think it won't be long because practicing like that is NEVER automatic. So my brain really learns.

3° The whole idea of rhythm reading is to free the mind of the pitch names (especially for those unfortunate enough to have caught the habit).

4° I developed these tools because no teacher or musician or book or website or forum could help me
get out of the groove I was stuck in.

When the period of tests will be finished (and successful), I intend to develop a website for those who think sightplaying is the good basis for autonomy and discovery.

Of course, everything I write is for people who are "inner-directed" and do not take their motivation from recitals, competitions or exams.
I expect that those master the zen art or sightplaying and its relationship with easy memorizing (though I'm not 100% sure this is the case).

If something is not clear in what I write, I apologize for the clumsiness of my explanations and I would appreciate that you ask me directly to make myself more clear.

It is not easy to write in a foreign language since I have always read about music in French.

Hope this makes it more clear for you.

I am not "selling" anything and I do not prove anything.

I just answered Pique's post because I felt she had the same motivation as me.

\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915734 - 04/29/03 10:33 AM Re: Sightreading technique
Praetorian_AD Offline
500 Post Club Member

Registered: 12/24/01
Posts: 717
Loc: England
 Quote:
Originally posted by ob1knabe:

Praetorian--maybe I missed this, but how did you do on your A levels? I hope that everything worked out for you.[/b]
No - you didn't miss it, I just didn't really post it up. I'm doing my A-level exams right now as a matter of fact, and they should be over by the end of June. If you're enquiring about the A-level music recital I posted up - I got an A on it!! (23/25) I was pretty chuffed! I was gonna post it up but I felt silly because the thread about the recital had spun off in some other direction (as they do) Thanks very much for asking!!
\:\)

Peter

Top
#915735 - 04/29/03 10:47 AM Re: Sightreading technique
Nina Offline
6000 Post Club Member

Registered: 08/13/01
Posts: 6467
Loc: Phoenix, AZ
Hi, Benedict:

I think I am following what you are saying. Let me try: when we read words, we don't stop and say, "Letter A, sounds like ah, letter P, sounds like 'pah'" and piece it together that way. (Even though that's how we all learned, the process becomes automatic pretty quickly.)

In the process of learning to read language, we quickly transfer from letter identification to sounds, then on to words, etc.

So, when reading music, you're saying you move from a conscious thought ("the note is C#, let me find it on the keyboard,") to an automatic identification of the note and the physical movement necessary to locate it on the keyboard.

And, if I'm on it so far, that process is made a lot easier for you by paying attention to the rhythm, not the note identification itself.

Makes sense to me. I'm thinking about my own sightreading, and I don't stop and identify the notes at all (except for the occasional note way off the staff, where I have to count those itty-bitty lines :p ). The challenge for me is linking the notes with the rhythm, as well. Until that is completed, it's just a mishmash of notes and sound.

Rhythm is at the essence of music, IMHO.

By the way, I'm a big fan of Pischna also. I think we may be the only two... seems like the other forumites use Hanon or Czerny more, if they use exercises at all.

Nina

Top
#915736 - 04/29/03 11:08 AM Re: Sightreading technique
BruceD Online   content
Yikes! 10000 Post Club Member

Registered: 05/26/01
Posts: 18236
Loc: Victoria, BC
Benedict:

I'm sorry I misunderstood what you were trying to say.

I've never heard of a method of (piano) study where one recites the pitch names of notes as (or before) one plays them. Certainly, I would never use (or need) such a system. Perhaps it would work for children starting out at the piano, otherwise it seems counterproductive.

As for determining rhythm, it did not occur to me that, (using your example of the WTC Prelude No 1) one would think of counting each sixteenth note in a quadruplet in 4/4 time. It is such a regular, straightforward rhythm, that it seems to me infinitely easier - and much more conducive to the flow of the piece - to simply count out the four beats and play four evenly spaced notes in each beat.

As I understand what you are saying - and it's possible I do not understand - this is making a straightforward rhythm more complex and par conséquent more difficult.

I guess the bottom line is: if it works for you, then you should use it.

Ah, well, that's the difficulty - some times - about trying to talk about music. It's difficult to accurately portray in words what we do in practice.

Regards,
_________________________
BruceD
- - - - -
Estonia 190

Top
#915737 - 04/29/03 11:57 AM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Bruce D,

What makes this forum both rich and complex is the differences of levels, experiences,goals.

From what you write, I gather that you can sightread any fugue of the WTC 1 (and probably 2) by opening the book and starting at the first bar.

That puts you in a very different league. So I suppose you can skip my posts which will have been useful if one person has related to them and find that a door which was closed before has begun to open.

A long time ago, I started a thread "Piano for dummies" and got a lot of negative feedback.
Well, here we are. There is a very little number of "dummies" around. I hope the haves are merciful.

About saying the names of the pitches, that is what I have done for many decades because I took the habit as a child and was NOT ONCE corrected by the seven teachers I've had.
As you say rightly, it slows down the whole process.

So for me rythm is an antidote and a way to debug the whole cognitive process.

Je viens de lire que tu etais prof de francais.

Content de te connaitre. \:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915738 - 04/29/03 12:11 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Nina,
"Rhythm is at the essence of music, IMHO."

IMHO too.

I wonder if rythm is not at the essence of Nature.

Somebody who likes Pischna and the Piano Shop on the Left bank cannot be all bad.
\:D

You understood me quite well : thanks to concentrating on the rythm, the process of reading pitches and putting the right finger on the right key is done unconsciously.

That is what I have experienced.

I think sightplaying Pischna is an incredible help.

What I am trying to create is a sheetmusic which will allow me to sightplay all scales in the chromatic order or the cycle of fifths.*
Thanks to Ryan's advice (whom I thank once more \:\) , I sightplay scales which puts an end to the nightmare of automatic memory playing which kills any joy.

My dream is to be the Hanon of sightreading. That would be a great revenge on standing for so long at the gates of Heaven outside.

The problem with Hanon IMHO is that they are two monotonous so that you memorize them and play mechanically easily. But the idea of a ritual that will develop technique is not bad.

Czerny ? I once asked on this forum. I got no reply.

Pischna is pleasant because it is based on the same idea as Hanon : a set of exercices that cover the basic skills. But the two hands do not play the same thing and it goes through seven keys so that when I sightplay it, a lot of things are processed by my brain while I just read the rythm.
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915739 - 04/29/03 01:00 PM Re: Sightreading technique
ryan Offline
1000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/04/01
Posts: 1995
Loc: Colorado
 Quote:
Originally posted by nina:
"Rhythm is at the essence of music, IMHO."[/b]
To expand on the same idea, to rhythm I would add pulse and pace, without which music is not music.

Czerny is great! I had a friend that could sightread pretty much anything by Czerny at or faster than the given tempi, which is really saying something because the metronome markings are usually pretty insane. This guy was the best sightreader I have ever seen. He was a natural, but he further developed his skills by reading lots of Czerny and anything else he could get his hands on.

Ryan

Top
#915740 - 04/29/03 01:06 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Ryan
 Quote:
to rhythm I would add pulse and pace, without which music is not music.
Of course. I take the word rythm in the broadest sense. The pulse is of course the basis, both a motor and a soul of music.

I will try and read Czerny see if it is fun.

\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915741 - 04/29/03 01:33 PM Re: Sightreading technique
piqué Offline
5000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/15/01
Posts: 5484
i have never heard of pischna. would you please post his full name and the names of some of the exercise books? i will also ask my teacher about him. i have been using bartok's mikrokosmos series for sight reading.

that is amazing, benedict, that you invented this antidote on your own. i learned about it from my teacher. she kept telling me i needed to always be aware of what beat of the measure i was playing, not which note. this i found very confusing. then, one day, when i was struggling note by note (yet again!) through some difficult mendelssohn, she taught me to name each of the sixteenths with the rhythm: "one ee and a two ee and a three ee and a four ee" and to say it out loud as i played!

with my focus moved to the rhythm, to my utter amazement, i was able to read right through the piece, in time, with all notes correct. it was miraculous, and my ability to read has been forever changed. i was so excited, it was very much like being able to read a book for the first time, after years of only seeing the individual letters.

she now says she is going to use me as the poster child for all her adult students. \:D

it has been described to me also this way: the music is a moving train, the rhythm is the engine, you feel the rhythm in your own pulse and you hop aboard the moving train and go for a ride.

works great for me!
_________________________
piqué

now in paperback:


Grand Obsession: A Piano Odyssey

Top
#915742 - 04/29/03 01:48 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Pique,

Please congratulate your teacher (and yourself) : I have never met anybody who had started thinking about the question.

With Pischna, you read 32nd notes o -ne e-e a-and a-a.Which allows you two read any problem like Fugue 1 of WTC 1 which has a strange rythm (strange for Bach : probably changed by his son Karl Philip Emmanuel to fit the spirit of the time).

[URL=http://www.google.fr/search?q=pischna&ie=ISO-8859-1&hl=fr&btnG=Recherche+Google&meta=]http://www.google.fr/search?q=pischna&ie=ISO-8859-1&hl=fr&btnG=Recherche+Google&meta=[/UR L]

(you can copy and paste in your navigator)

Good luck.
And welcome in the Pischna fan club ! \:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915743 - 04/29/03 04:10 PM Re: Sightreading technique
ryan Offline
1000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/04/01
Posts: 1995
Loc: Colorado
I don't know what to say... this is of course most useful stuff. But how are people not taught it in their piano lessons?!?! I start my students counting the rhythms out loud from day one. There is also singing, clapping, marching, knee slapping, etc. My wife was laughing the other day because she heard our son practicing his quarternote rest exercise "ta ta ta shhhh" in the back seat of the car \:\)

Anyway, congrats on your discoveries! I am stunned, though, that it wasn't taught by your first teachers \:\(

Ryan

Top
#915744 - 04/29/03 04:15 PM Re: Sightreading technique
Nina Offline
6000 Post Club Member

Registered: 08/13/01
Posts: 6467
Loc: Phoenix, AZ
Ryan, I'm with you. But great that folks are getting it.

My daughter's teacher used words, which I've found are oddly contagious:

Chips (1 beat)
Salsa (2 beats)
Enchilada (4 beats, e.g., 16th notes)

Particularly with Mozart, I find myself singing "enchilada enchilada enchilada" when working out a lot of his 16th note passages (and with Mozart, there are a LOT of these!)

Nina

Top
#915745 - 04/29/03 05:02 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Ryan,

The system in France separates music education called "solfege" and practice of an instrument.

In schools, music classes are usually those where children do not pay any attention and throw things at one another.

Because it is more theorical and historical than practical.

French education has this tendancy to rely very much in formal knowledge and intellectualization.

There is absolutely no singing (choirs) or youth orchestras in the education except in some private schools.

My children went to such a school so they had a class orchestra and they developed good musicals skills without any theory whatsoever. But they are good natural musicians.

In the conservatories, children have to study two years of solfege before beginning the instrument.

My own experience is of a very long time ago. But I am not sure, things have changed very much.

The piano teacher relies on the solfege class to deal with rythm and reading pitches.
So, he concentrates on interpretation and not on the process of learning the piece.

I have had 7 teachers since my childhood : from the conservatory when I was 8 to the Ecole Normale (founded by Cortot where I started again with Mikrokosmos), two students of Yvonne Lefebure and two Julliard School graduates.

None, I repeat, none ever took one second to concentrate on the rythm. So I learnt the pieces by memorizing by repetition. And I used the names of the pitches to memorize.

If one of them had understood the mechanics of learning a piece, they would have stopped me straight away and shown me a process like the one I had to develop painfully. It took me more than 10 years !

I have read all the books I could find about sightreading. None ever spoke about what this thread is about.

So the reality is that both your experiences Ryan and Nina and mine are real.

If a child begins with what you do with him and you apply it to every piece he learns, the skills will be part of him for all his life.

If you don't or if you separate solfege from playing pieces, then the result will be much more left to chance.

I have noticed that many good musicians do not sightread naturally. In my opinion, the reason is that they jump too soon to memorization.

Of course, this is my idea now. I might change in a few months.

It is nice sharing with you.

And the proof is in the hard work at the piano.

Ryan, your insisting on the scales has taken the emphasis away from the pieces and more on the reading process per se. It has freed completely my mind.

There still is much discovering to do. But now that I feel autonomous, every minute is a minute of joy.

\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915746 - 04/29/03 05:13 PM Re: Sightreading technique
ryan Offline
1000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/04/01
Posts: 1995
Loc: Colorado
Benedict,

Yes, I am aware that your experience is all too real. I have seen it before. I am just saddened by it. A good *teacher* should have been able to see what you were doing and help you fix it at the ground level.

I am quite pleased that the scales helped. \:\)

Ryan

Top
#915747 - 04/29/03 05:26 PM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Thank you, Ryan.

I think good teachers do the right thing with children or beginning adults.

Once the adult has some practice, even if it is completely bugged, the teacher will concentrate on the piece without using the same process that he uses for a beginner.

I think a good process should be useful at all levels and any age.

If one level of the skill is not correct, you have to go down one level and iterate to go right at the bottom if necessary.

And then you can move right at the top by checking that each level is debugged.

I hope I am clear.

Today, I sowed tomatoes seeds on my balcony garden. I hope I will eat good tomatoes in September.

What has it got to do with scales or sightreading ?

\:D
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915748 - 04/29/03 10:32 PM Re: Sightreading technique
piqué Offline
5000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/15/01
Posts: 5484
yes, my experience was much like benedict's, with former teachers. i just returned to my "good" teacher, the one who taught me how to read, after her year's sabbatical, because my new teacher was making the same mistake all the previous teachers made: thinking that we just focus on interpretation and painful process of memorizing instead of learning how to learn, learning how to read.

my "good" teacher commented that it was a real shame that no one had taught me this before. i think many teachers believe an adult student won't be willing to return to kindergarten level to correct a faulty foundation. the new teacher made this same mistake, even after i insisted that i didn't want to focus on interpretation when i didn't yet have my learning skills fully developed. she thought it was babyish for me to go back and fill in the blanks of the things i never learned.

i found this with my earlier teachers, too.

i believe it is one of the hazards of being an adult student. it also didn't help that i don't *need* to be able to read, i can do a lot just with playing by ear. but i finally reached a level of music where that couldn't help me so much any more.

i interviewed a lot of teachers in the past few years. most of them, once they hear me play, think they don't really need to teach me techniques of music, that i just need "coaching." they are unperceptive. they think that all i have to do is memorize because i am able to play musically. they don't see what i huge handicap i have. those are the teachers i walk away from.

thankfully i am finally back with the only one who has been able to help me make *genuine* progress.
_________________________
piqué

now in paperback:


Grand Obsession: A Piano Odyssey

Top
#915749 - 04/30/03 06:57 AM Re: Sightreading technique
benedict Offline
2000 Post Club Member

Registered: 09/21/02
Posts: 2519
Loc: European Union
Pique,

We have had exactly the same experience.

I used to play Satie's Gnossienne n°1 and I put so much feeling into it that people thought I was an accomplished pianist.

And when they asked me to play other pieces, I just couldn't.

I then memorized WTC 1st Prelude and fugue.

My Julliar teacher found it very good.

And I was begging : teach me how to read, for Heaven's sake.

He didn't have a clue what I was talking about.

We seem to be on the same road now : sightplaying has to been conquered at normal speed for the pieces you love (for me it's WTC 1) and then, I'll concentrate on the process that leads to fluent sightplaying to playing without the sheetmusic. But without the horrible process of memorizing like I have done it up to now.

I have the intuition that memorization will be a joy. But the next step on my roadmap is : fluent sightplaying.

One step at a time is the perfect rythm once one has the right tools.

\:\)
_________________________
Benedict

Top
#915750 - 04/30/03 10:42 AM Re: Sightreading technique
piqué Offline
5000 Post Club Member

Registered: 06/15/01
Posts: 5484
 Quote:
Originally posted by benedict:
Pique,

We have had exactly the same experience.

I used to play Satie's Gnossienne n°1 and I put so much feeling into it that people thought I was an accomplished pianist.

And when they asked me to play other pieces, I just couldn't.

I then memorized WTC 1st Prelude and fugue.

My Julliar teacher found it very good.

And I was begging : teach me how to read, for Heaven's sake.

He didn't have a clue what I was talking about.
....

One step at a time is the perfect rythm once one has the right tools.

\:\) [/b]
yes, exactly!

these teachers can hear that i am a musician, but fail to notice that i am not a pianist. they are dumbfounded when the lessons begin and after six months i am still stumbling through the same works we began with without confidence.

then they compound it by continuing to focus on musical ideas and interpretation--which i am already light years ahead of most of them on, anyway--and neglecting the basics. even when i insist on the basics, they are clueless!! how much time was wasted, and how discouraged i have been.

my current teacher respects my ear, respects my musicianship, and also uses flash cards if necessary for the skills i don't have. my progress with her is breathtaking to me.

i want to know everything you have learned about reading, benedict. i could not find the link you posted on pischna. please just type in here his full name and the correct names of some of his works or books. i would be very grateful.
_________________________
piqué

now in paperback:


Grand Obsession: A Piano Odyssey

Top
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >

What's Hot!!

Forums Rules & Help
-------------------
ADVERTISE
on Piano World

The world's most popular piano web site.
-------------------
PIANO BOOKS
Interesting books about the piano, pianists, piano history, biographies, memoirs and more!
(ad) Yamaha CP Music Rest Promo
Yamaha CP Music Rest Promo
Ad (Seiler/Knabe)
Knabe Pianos
(ad) HAILUN Pianos
Hailun Pianos - Click for More
(125ad) Dampp Chaser
Dampp Chaser Piano Life Saver
(ad) Lindeblad Piano
Lindeblad Piano Restoration
(ad) Piano Music Sale - Dover Publications
Piano Music Sale
Sheet Music Plus (125)
Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale
New Topics - Multiple Forums
Please help me to find out the pattern of this Cdim7
by SZ54
11/28/14 08:12 PM
3 sensors per key vs 4?
by AnimistFvR
11/28/14 07:55 PM
Request For The Pursuit Of Knowledge
by Louis Podesta
11/28/14 07:09 PM
Kawai K500 or Seiler ED126
by Mizar
11/28/14 07:03 PM
3 sensors per key vs 4?
by AnimistFvR
11/28/14 06:58 PM
Forum Stats
77083 Members
42 Forums
159431 Topics
2341972 Posts

Max Online: 15252 @ 03/21/10 11:39 PM
Gift Ideas for Music Lovers!
Find the Perfect Gift for the Music Lovers on your List!
Visit our online store today.

Visit our online store for gifts for music lovers

 
Help keep the forums up and running with a donation, any amount is appreciated!
Or by becoming a Subscribing member! Thank-you.
Donate   Subscribe
 
Our Piano Related Classified Ads
|
Dealers | Tuners | Lessons | Movers | Restorations | Pianos For Sale | Sell Your Piano |

Advertise on Piano World
| Subscribe | Piano World | PianoSupplies.com | Advertise on Piano World | Donate | Link to Us | Classifieds |
| |Contact | Privacy | Legal | About Us | Site Map | Free Newsletter | Press Room |


copyright 1997 - 2014 Piano World ® all rights reserved
No part of this site may be reproduced without prior written permission